top of page

Mastering the Art of Balance: Authentic Leadership and the Juggling of Self and Team

Heather Garner

In the ever-evolving world of business, leadership is often mistaken for authority. Many organizations continue to promote high-performing individual contributors into management roles, assuming their technical excellence will translate into leadership prowess. However, leadership is not about being the best doer—it is about being the best balancer.


Without self-awareness and internal equilibrium, leaders struggle to manage the complex dynamics of a team. They become reactive instead of proactive, focusing on short-term appearances rather than long-term growth. This article explores why many managers lack the ability to balance their teams and how shifting from control-based leadership to authentic leadership fosters trust, innovation, and sustainable success.


The Juggling Analogy: Master Yourself Before Managing a Team

Think of leadership as a juggling act. Imagine trying to keep three or more balls in the air when you’ve never learned how to handle even one. The key isn’t just about adding more balls—it’s about developing the mastery of balance before attempting to manage others.


  • Motive and Intention: Many leaders unconsciously operate from a place of seeking external validation—constantly trying to impress their superiors instead of fostering an environment of genuine success. This leads to performance-based leadership rather than purpose-driven leadership.

  • The Pitfall of Insecurity: Leaders who haven’t mastered themselves often fall into a cycle of reactive leadership—where they only address problems when higher-ups are watching, rather than proactively guiding their teams to consistent excellence. Insecure leaders prioritize looking good over being good, which creates a culture where employees are more focused on avoiding failure than achieving excellence.


A leader who cannot balance themselves—emotionally, mentally, physically, and spiritually—will find it nearly impossible to balance the needs of an entire team.


The Regional Boss Scenario: A Case Study in Reactive Leadership

Have you ever seen a workplace that suddenly goes into panic mode because a regional boss or auditor is scheduled to visit?


  • Employees are suddenly rushing to clean up neglected areas.

  • Management barks orders to ensure everyone follows dress codes, policies, and presentation standards—things that should have been in place all along.

  • The focus shifts entirely from creating an outstanding client experience to staging a show for the visiting superior.


What does this reveal?


It signals that leadership is reactive, not proactive. If an establishment only shines when someone important is watching, it’s not truly well-run—it’s a house of cards. The workforce isn’t empowered to maintain excellence daily; instead, they’re conditioned to react to pressure and avoid criticism.


A strong leader creates a workplace where business as usual is already excellent—whether or not a superior is visiting.


The Boss’s Office Scenario: The Leadership That Silences Growth

Have you ever been in a one-sided meeting with a boss who won’t stop talking?


  • The leader spends the entire conversation telling you what’s wrong and what you need to fix.

  • They never pause to ask:

    • What do you see as working well?

    • What improvements do you think would be beneficial?

    • What resources do you need to succeed?


Leaders who talk more than they listen unknowingly disempower their teams. They assume they have all the answers while ignoring the people who are closest to the actual work.


True Leadership is a Two-Way Street

The best leaders:✅ Ask more than they tell.Empower employees to share ideas.Collaborate instead of dictate.


In an effective organization, employees aren’t just pegs in a wheel. They are active contributors with insights that should shape company strategy—not just follow top-down directives.


Spotting Leadership Imbalance: The Signs Are Everywhere

How can you tell if a leader is out of balance? There are signs everywhere—not just in how they manage their teams, but in how they manage themselves.


One of the most visible indicators of imbalance is how a leader takes care of their own physical vessel.


  • Do they prioritize their well-being, or do they neglect themselves?

  • Are they disciplined in maintaining their energy and physical health, or do they show clear signs of burnout and neglect?

  • If a leader struggles to manage their own well-being, how can they be trusted to manage yours?


This isn’t about perfection or body-shaming—it’s about recognizing that a leader’s ability to balance their own life is a direct reflection of their ability to balance a team or organization. Just as you wouldn’t trust a financial advisor drowning in debt, why would you trust a leader who doesn’t prioritize their own stability to be responsible for yours?


Leaders set the tone. When they neglect their own well-being—whether physically, emotionally, or mentally—they unintentionally send a message: imbalance is acceptable.


Growth Over Gutting: The Right Approach to Developing a Balanced Organization

This does not mean looking at your organization with fresh eyes and deciding to clean house, letting people go to “hire smarter.” Great leadership is not about replacing people—it’s about developing them.


  • Authentic conversations should be the first step. Engage in open, honest discussions with your team members. Understand their challenges, strengths, and areas for growth.

  • Invest in those who want to grow with the company. Many employees are simply waiting for an opportunity to develop skills they may not have had the chance to refine.

  • Encourage collaborative growth. Pair employees with opposing strengths to learn from each other, set parameters for open, balanced feedback, and tackle long-neglected projects.


This approach doesn’t just strengthen your team—it solves real business challenges while fostering personal and professional growth. It’s a win-win-win:✅ The company gains fresh solutions.Employees develop in meaningful ways.Leadership builds a culture of continuous improvement.


For More on Mastering Leadership Balance:


The future of leadership isn’t about controlling others—it’s about mastering yourself. Are you ready to make the shift?


Please share your insights in comments, we'd love to hear your perspective.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page